Mobile App or Mobile Web

Which is more appropriate for Travel Industry?

Since the launch of iPhone the mobile industry has been in a flux. It has witnessed lot of innovations since then. Today, more choices are available to the user than ever before which has resulted in a fragmented market. It has complicated matters for every organization which wants to reach out to their consumers through mobile. There are too many platforms to be supported and there is no standardization. Some industry segments have not made any significant move to reach out to their consumer through mobile platform and are playing a waiting game – waiting for the technology to mature. However, travel industry cannot afford to do that.

Mobile phone is a personal device – more personal than the “personal” computer. You might lend your PC to coworker or a friend for few hours but can you imagine lending your mobile phone?

Travel is also a personal activity. Nobody else can do it for you. Unlike retail shopping you cannot get your friend or family member to do it for you. Though you might get somebody to do the planning for you, it is necessary for you to be aware of the logistics when you travel.

So, the match between travel and mobile seems to be a match made in heaven where a personal device meets a personal activity. Naturally, there is a lot of interest in travel industry on reaching out to the customer through the mobile. In this fragmented technology scenario, one of the following two strategies can be followed.

  1. Take the shortcut and extend your web site and make it accessible from the browser in the mobile phone
  2. Do it the hard way by incurring the cost of developing a native application for multiple mobile platforms

Advantages of Browser Based Mobile Application (Mobile Web)

  • The variability across different types of handset is minimal compared to mobile application. You have to take care of only browser specific differences and the difference of screen size – unlike mobile app where the total programming environment including the programming language is different
  • No need for the user to download and install any application on the handset – this can be a stumbling block for first time user
  • The existing web site with modifications can be extended to the mobile – unlike mobile app where the application has to be develop ground up

Advantages of Native Mobile Application (Mobile App)

  • The application can be location aware – unlike a mobile web application which do not have access the location information
  • Offline working is possible – availability of internet connection and bandwidth cannot yet be taken for granted, especially for a traveler
  • Can access the native mobile functionality like phone book, calendar & camera – for an application to be effective on a device which is personal, it needs to interface with functionalities which gives the device the personal flavor

What about a Hybrid Approach?

There are several possibilities:

  1. Invoke the browser for the native application and show a specific web page – the problem is you lose control
  2. Make a browser instance within your application and show the page – you have better control but all mobiles do not support this feature

None of these alternatives reduce the headache of having to maintain different applications for different platform.

A way forward in the future may be to access handset specific functionality from the browser through browser plug-in? Please correct me if I am wrong, but to the best of my knowledge it is not possible yet.

What is the Future?

Though predicting the future is always hazardous, the following can be predicted without too much risk.

  • Smart phones will become much more powerful
  • Network access speeds will become faster
  • Touch screen and multi-touch will become standard
  • Mobile will remain a personal device and it will become an extension of us

Unlike PC, which can be thought of as a dumb terminal accessing applications in the cloud, mobile phones cannot be treated that way. It already behaves as an extension of our memory and it is also going to act as our identity.

So, the conclusion – I do not see native mobile applications going away – especially when we are on the move!

5 Responses to “Mobile App or Mobile Web”
  1. I know this website presents quality based articles and extra information, is
    there any other website which offers these kinds of data in quality?

  2. Mahadevan says:

    Application for Travel industry should be addressed through web/browser based instead of a native application;
    The application is for a wider audience with different accessing options each having different kind of phones.
    The advantage of providing a web based approach is we don’t have to decide based on the market share of different phone, Which will keep changing
    The necessities of a traveler can mostly be satisfied through a browser,what is the extra benefits he will get with native application and how much is that needed?
    The adaptation to different browsers is much more easier/feasible/quick.
    As the mobile phones are becoming smarter, browser and net access will become no more an additional features.
    Also all your predictions are already a reality and like network speeds will make a browsing experience more friendly.
    A user may change his phone any time and which is also a common case now.. which means he has install the application for the device again and will it support for the new devise?
    We should weigh the pros and cons between a native and web based if,
    If the application is for controlled group like sales/marketing people of an organization in the field.
    If the application is a special kind of application – not a general purpose..

    For a general consumer downloading a native application and using it for something like a travel is not friendly.
    If he has to do this.. will he do for one for air travel , one for rail and one for metros???which does not seems
    ok..instead if he can use the browser for all it is much more simpler..
    Ii have already seen people use the browser to see when the next bus is at a particular stop and plan accordingly.


    The application can be location aware – unlike a mobile web application which do not have access the location information.
    First of all the application can be location aware.. when i access Google from my mobile through wifi, it can say i am from Bangalore.. or do we need more finer refinement?

  3. Josiah says:

    Why choose between native and web apps when you can easily have both? is a service that gives web apps a way to be sold in App Stores. All we need is the URL of the web app and we can put it in the iPhone App Store, Android Market, Palm Catalog (when it opens to general 3rd party apps) and desktop apps on Mac, Windows and Linux.

    Prices start at $149.

    Mobile web app authors maintain their own code and hosting – while being able to update their application without resubmitting the app to each store.

  4. Deepesh says:

    As you said, once the network access speeds faster and always available, and with some effort in the Mobile browsers (like Standardization, Applet/ActiveX like support), the time and cost of developing a Web based solution will always be better. That too with all the things that could have been done with a native application possible in Web app.

Check out what others are saying...
  1. […] …there will be less incentive to build native mobile applications (Mobile App or Mobile Web) […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: